The Fall of Indian Football: A Gloom That Runs Deep

Indian football is experiencing one of its most challenging periods in recent memory. The national team's global ranking has plummeted to 127th, a significant drop from the 99th position in July 2023, making the concerning trends difficult to overlook. Recent performances have cast doubt on India's chances of qualifying for the AFC Asian Cup 2027. A frustrating home draw against Bangladesh and an unexpected defeat to a lower-ranked Hong Kong team have deepened the crisis for Indian football. India is currently at the bottom of a four-team group. More painful than the results is the predictable nature of this decline. For those aware of the systemic issues within the Indian Football set up, this downturn is disappointing but not surprising.

The reasons for this decline are intertwined, primarily stemming from governance failures, coaching dynamics, player development challenges, and an overall lack of competitive urgency.

1. Administrative Apathy: Governance in Freefall

At the heart of the crisis is a vacuum of leadership. The current football administration, lacking experience and foresight, appears to be navigating one of India’s most beloved sports with no compass. Technical incompetence, absence of a strategic roadmap, and internal politics have taken precedence over the sport itself. The people at the helm are simply not equipped for the demands of modern football governance.

2. Faulty Decision: The Dual Role Blunder

In a move that defies logic, Manolo Márquez was appointed head coach of the national team while retaining responsibilities at the club level. Dual roles might have worked in amateur eras—but today’s international football requires singular focus, strategic planning, and undivided commitment. Manolo had promise, but not the structure or support to succeed.

This divides attention and resources, obstructing the formation of a world-class team. The decision by management to cut costs on full-time positions instead of focusing on the national team's needs is a major drawback. When the coach is overextended, the team is negatively impacted.

3. The Chhetri Return: A Missed Opportunity for Closure

Sunil Chhetri’s return from retirement, likely driven by emotional appeals and institutional vacuum, has not only yielded underwhelming results but risks overshadowing his illustrious legacy. He deserved a curtain call, not a comeback under chaos. His brand as a legend has taken an unjust hit in the absence of a stable supporting cast.

4. Collapse in Team Dynamics

Since the AFC Asian Cup 2023, India hasn’t won an official match. The inability to score goals stems from a deeper malaise—disrupted team setups, internal misalignment between the coach and management, and a lack of cohesion. A team fragmented off the field cannot perform as one on it.

5. Weak Competitive Landscape

While Indian footballers are undeniably talented, the competitive landscape leaves much to be desired. The league structure and the quality of matches do not prepare players adequately for mid-level Asian teams.

Playing in 30 or more matches a season is insufficient if those matches do not present real challenges. Training against higher-caliber opponents is vital for skill enhancement and cultivating a competitive mentality. For example, teams that regularly compete against top-tier opponents report a noticeable uptick in performance as evidenced by a 25% increase in winning percentages.

The current weak environment stifles growth, resulting in lackluster performances during crucial international fixtures.

6. Lack of Competitiveness Among Players

The widespread absence of competitiveness among Indian football players is concerning. Out of approximately 70 players, only 28 are selected for national camps. This has led to a sense of security among many players about their positions, irrespective of their performance, resulting in complacency.

This lack of urgency not only stifles ambition but also discourages improvement. To foster a competitive atmosphere, the player pool should expand significantly—potentially to over 300. A broader selection allows for a more stringent selection process, where competition becomes vital for success.

Recognizing and rewarding talent should energize players to push their limits and excel.

7. Trust Deficit with the Fans

Disenchanted and frustrated, Indian football fans—who once stood as the soul of the sport—are now its most vocal critics. The demand to include OCI/PIO players reflects not just a tactical need but a loss of faith in domestic football systems. When fans stop believing, pressure mounts, and performance dips further.

8. Negative Perception & Alienation of Stakeholders

From investors to brands, from sponsors to broadcasters—everyone is stepping back. With no good stories emerging and with leadership constantly under fire, Indian football has become an unattractive proposition commercially. A sport that once inspired patriotism now stirs disbelief and detachment.

9. No Champions, No Celebration

While other Indian sports leap forward—with medals, world rankings, and global acclaim—football stands still. Or worse, regresses. Not a single narrative lifts spirits. No new icons. No rising stars. Just news of yet another missed chance, another slide in the FIFA rankings—from 99 in July 2023 to 127 now, and a predicted drop to 133.

10. Accountability Lost, Plans Forgotten

Where is the strategy? Where is the framework that fosters talent, develops top-tier infrastructure, and instills national pride? Within the system, mere survival appears to be the sole focus. Roles are safeguarded, duties are avoided, and the broader perspective is neglected. There is no vision. Only crisis management.

A Gasp for Breath

This could be considered the bleakest period in Indian football. However, amidst the despair arises a question of determination. How much lower must we sink before we begin to ascend? Where is the responsibility, the willingness to acknowledge failure, and the bravery to address it?

Football reflects the sporting spirit of a nation. In a country with 1.4 billion people, it's deeply ironic that the beautiful game finds it hard to thrive. The true victory India needs is off the field—through reform, leadership, and a dedication to excellence.

In the meantime, may God bless Indian football.